Criminal Law Blog
October 02, 2009
This blog is the second of two about section 12.44 of the Texas Penal Code.
If you had to accept either a 12.44(a) and a 12.44(b), then it’s probably obvious that you would prefer a 12.44(b) over a 12.44(a). But then, it’s probably equally obvious that except for very unusual circumstances, you probably won’t be offered a 12.44(b).
So the question isn’t which would you prefer. The question is: under what circumstances would you want to accept a 12.44(a)?
Here are some factors that would make the difference between accepting and declining an offer for a 12.44(a). The most common is if you already have been locked up for a while and you’ve been getting 2 for 1 credit or 3 for 1 credit and you know the State’s case is fairly strong. In that case, a 12.44(a) might look pretty attractive, since it can get you out of jail faster.
Another factor would be pre-existing criminal history.
Many people who have not been convicted of a felony before strongly resist entering a plea of guilty to a felony because a felony on their record because that can kill their chances to get a good job.
But if you already have two or more felony convictions or probations, an additional state jail felony conviction may not seem to be quite as big a deal, career-wise.
A factor that bears on whether you’ll even be offered a 12.44(a) is whether the State has already reduced a possession case to a State Jail Felony. For example, the weight range for a State Jail Felony possession of cocaine is anything up to, but not including, 1 gram.
But suppose a defendant possesses exactly 1 gram of cocaine. One 1/100th of a gram less and the defendant would be looking at a State Jail Felony. Under those circumstances, some felony prosecutors will see fit to proceed on the case as if it were a State Jail Felony charge, and not the 3rd degree felony that it really is. If the prosecutor has reduced the charge that way, he may not look very kindly upon a counter-offer of county jail time under 12.44(a).
He won’t agree to reduce the charge in exchange for nothing and then be asked to also reduce the punishment to misdemeanor level.
